Spending $3,000 a Year on Repairs? It Might Be Time for a New Car
At first, a car repair bill may feel manageable. Then another one hits. And another. Before long, what once felt like a “paid-off” car can start to feel like a money pit. How do you know when you’ve crossed the line from smart maintenance to throwing money at a problem that won’t go away?
Auto experts offer some tips on when to throw in the towel.
Discover Next: 6 Cars You Should Avoid Buying Used
Read More: Start Growing Your Net Worth With Smarter Tracking
How Much Is Too Much? The $3,000 Repair Threshold
There’s no single number that applies to every car, but once repair costs start approaching a meaningful share of the vehicle’s value — or around $3,000 a year — it may be time to reassess.
Jonathan Olszewski, automotive technology instructor at Farmingdale School District, suggested that if you’re spending nearly as much each year on repairs as you do on car payments themselves, “it’s time to move on.”
A similar benchmark, according to Patrick Peterson, auto expert and team lead at GoodCar, is “when the average yearly repair costs reach or get close to 50% of the car’s current market value.”
The Hidden Costs of Keeping an Aging Car
Older cars will require more maintenance, with parts like belts, hoses and bushings degrading and rust compromising seals, Olszewski said. However, constant maintenance is not “normal” either.
Additionally, Peterson pointed out that many older cars use more gas than newer cars, leading to a bigger spend each year, even during times when gas prices aren’t sky high.
He added that there are also downstream costs associated with ongoing car repairs. “When your car is always in the shop, you may need to rent a vehicle or take time off work … which can be stressful and a waste of time.”
The Burden of Unreliability Most Drivers Ignore
Even if a car still runs, when a vehicle becomes “a constant source of stress that threatens your ability to get to work reliably, you need to simplify your life and find something more dependable,” Olszewski said.
A car that already costs you a lot in repairs now may need even more costly repairs in the future, Peterson added.
When It Still Makes Sense To Repair Your Car
Not every big repair means it’s time to replace your vehicle, however. For example, Olszewski said, if you own a car worth around $8,000 and the shop says it’ll cost $1,600 to fix, for example, that investment should buy you several more years of service.
Spending on a necessary repair is a perfectly reasonable short-term move while you plan for a replacement down the line, as well, Peterson said.
The Biggest Mistake: Waiting Too Long to Decide
Many drivers don’t decide to buy a new car until it’s forced on them, unfortunately, which is when it gets expensive.
“The biggest mistake is waiting until the car is on the back of a tow truck,” Olszewski said.
Having a solid emergency fund in place can help with surprise car expenses, but if you’re continually blowing through that for car repairs, it might be time for a new car.
How To Replace Your Car Without Wrecking Your Budget
A $3,000 repair bill isn’t automatically a dealbreaker. But when those costs become routine, start rivaling a car payment or eat up a large share of your car’s value, you’re just delaying a bigger decision.
If you've paid out more than $3,000 in car repairs recently, it's a good idea to start saving for a new car, just in case.
This article was provided by MoneyLion.com for informational purposes only and should not be construed as financial, legal or tax advice.
More From MoneyLion:
Discover a Smarter Way to Keep Unexpected Expenses From Derailing Your Budget
Got $20 To Spend at Dollar Tree? Consider These Fine Spring Items
Be Honest — Do You Have Enough Cash at Home in Case of a National Emergency?
