Can’t decide between White Elephant vs Secret Santa? 🎁 Good news – you don’t have to choose! These beloved holiday gift exchanges each bring their own brand of festive fun, whether you’re celebrating with family, friends, or the office crew. 🎄
While Secret Santa creates thoughtful one-on-one connections, the White Elephant game adds a playful dash of chaos with its gift-stealing shenanigans.
The best part? Both are great gift exchange games for large groups and are incredibly flexible – you can set any budget 💰 Let’s get into how White Elephant vs Secret Santa compare!
Up your Holiday gift game! MoneyLion’s WOW membership offers cashback opportunities on brands you love to exclusive member deals!
What is the white elephant game?
The White Elephant gift exchange (also known as yankee swap or dirty santa) is a hilarious party game where guests bring wrapped, often quirky or amusing gifts that anyone might enjoy.
Most Office fans remember White Elephant as the gift exchange game Michael forced everyone into during the “Christmas Party” episode (Season 2), when Phyllis’ homemade oven mitt sent Michael Scott into a classic spiral. 🎄😅
Unlike traditional gift exchanges, the fun comes from the chaotic element of stealing presents from other players, leading to unexpected surprises and playful competition.
Whether the gifts are genuinely nice finds, regifted treasures, or deliberately silly items, it’s the perfect icebreaker that turns gift-giving into an entertaining spectacle where no one knows what they’ll end up with until the very end. 🎭
How do you play white elephant Christmas game?
When it comes to how to play White Elephant, the rules are simple enough. To start, each player brings one wrapped gift and draws a random number to determine the play order.
Player #1 picks and unwraps any gift from the pile. Then, each following player can either steal an already-opened gift (forcing that person to choose another) or unwrap a new one from the pile. 🎯
To keep things fair, a single gift can only be stolen up to 3 times per round, and you can’t immediately steal back a gift that was just taken from you. 🔄 The game continues until everyone has a gift. 😈
What is the secret santa game?
Secret Santa 🎅 is a holiday gift exchange where each person in a group is randomly assigned to give a gift to one other person, while keeping their identity as the gift-giver a secret until the reveal.
It’s a popular in offices between coworkers, among friends, and with families as it reduces the total number of gifts each person needs to buy while maintaining the fun and mystery of holiday gift-giving. ✨
Secret Santa rules explained 📝
Each participant puts their name in a hat 🎩 and draws someone else’s name (if you draw your own, put it back and try again).
Keep your drawn name secret – this person will be the one you buy a gift for! The group typically agrees on a spending limit beforehand to keep things fair. On the chosen gift exchange day, everyone brings their wrapped gift with the recipient’s name on it. Gifts are distributed and opened one at a time, with each person finally discovering who their Secret Santa was!
Some groups like to add fun twists, like leaving small mystery gifts or clues leading up to the main exchange day. Just remember: the key to the game is keeping your recipient’s identity a secret until the final reveal!
Recommended: 30 Christmas Gift Ideas That Are Easy on the Wallet
What is the difference between White Elephant and Secret Santa?
While both are awesome gift exchange games for large groups, there are some basic differences in the rules for White Elephant and Secret Santa rules. Let’s look at how they compare.
Gift Purpose: 🎯 Secret Santa involves buying a specific gift for an assigned person, while White Elephant requires bringing a general gift anyone might enjoy.
Gift Style: 🎁 Secret Santa tends to feature thoughtful, personalized presents, whereas White Elephant encourages fun, quirky, or even gag gifts.
Gift Movement: 🔄 In Secret Santa, you keep the gift specifically chosen for you, but White Elephant allows players to “steal” gifts from each other during the game.
Game Secrecy: 🤫 Secret Santa maintains mystery until the final reveal, while White Elephant is played openly with everyone watching each choice and steal.
Budget Rules: 💰 Secret Santa typically enforces a strict budget everyone must follow, but White Elephant allows for a bit more flexibility within a suggested price range.
Time Frame: ⏰ Secret Santa builds anticipation over days or weeks, while White Elephant is played entirely during one lively gathering.
How to Choose: White Elephant vs Secret Santa 🤔
White Elephant Best For: Large office parties, groups that don’t know each other well, fun-loving crowds who enjoy competition, parties wanting more entertainment value, or when you’d rather focus more on the game than the gifts.
Secret Santa Best For: Close friend groups or family, professional office environments, when you prefer meaningful gifts, groups that enjoy personal touches, or when you’re looking to foster closer relationships. It’s also great if you’re looking to set budgets or enjoy building anticipation.
Recommended: Holiday Shopping: 15 Hacks to Get More for Less
Final thoughts
Whether you choose the chaotic fun of White Elephant or the thoughtful tradition of Secret Santa, both games bring their own special magic to holiday gatherings! 🎄
Remember: White Elephant shines when you want an entertaining party game with lots of laughs (and maybe a few playful gift-stealing battles 😈), while Secret Santa is perfect for creating meaningful moments and personal connections.
And hey, if you really can’t decide – or if you’re feeling brave like Michael Scott – you could always start with Secret Santa and switch to White Elephant mid-party! 🎁 ✨
Up your Holiday gift game! MoneyLion’s WOW membership offers cashback opportunities on brands you love to exclusive member deals!
FAQs
Why is it called White Elephant?
The term comes from the historical practice of the King of Siam (now Thailand) gifting rare white elephants to courtiers he disliked, as the animals were expensive to maintain yet couldn’t be refused or given away. The modern gift exchange game got this name because the gifts, like white elephants, are often more burdensome or amusing than valuable.
What’s the difference between Dirty Santa vs White Elephant?
They’re essentially the same game with different names – Dirty Santa is just the Southern U.S. term for White Elephant, with both involving gift-stealing and unwrapping in turns.
How do you play White Elephant?
Each person brings a wrapped gift, draws numbers for turn order, and when it’s your turn you can either choose a new wrapped gift to open or steal an already-opened gift from another player.
What is Dirty Santa?
Dirty Santa is simply another name for White Elephant, popular in the Southern United States, where players bring wrapped gifts and can either choose to open a new gift or “steal” from others during their turn.
What are the Secret Santa rules?
Each person randomly draws another participant’s name and secretly buys a gift for that person, keeping their identity hidden until the final gift exchange. The key is maintaining the mystery while staying within the agreed-upon budget.
