Cash Advance or Payday Loan? Understanding Your Options

When you need fast cash, you might find yourself choosing between a cash advance vs payday loan and other short-term borrowing options. But not all quick-cash solutions are created equal, and knowing the difference can help you avoid costly mistakes.

So, should you go for a cash advance vs payday loan? Which one costs less in the long run? And more importantly are there better alternatives? Let’s explore.

---

MoneyLion helps you find personal loan offers from trusted lenders, giving you up to $50,000 to cover your expenses without the high fees of payday loans and cash advances.

---

What is a cash advance?

A cash advance is a short-term borrowing option that allows you to access cash quickly, usually against a credit card limit or earned wages. Cash advances offer more flexibility in repayment but they still come with costs that borrowers should consider.

There are two main types of cash advances:

• Credit card cash advance. This allows you to withdraw cash from your credit card at an ATM or bank. The amount is limited by your card’s cash advance limit, and interest starts accruing immediately. Fees typically range from 3% to 5% of the amount withdrawn, and interest rates can be 15% to 30% APR, depending on your card’s terms.
• Earned Wage Access (EWA). EWA services, like Instacash, allow employees to access a portion of their earned wages before payday. Unlike credit card cash advances, these services often don’t charge interest and may not have mandatory fees, making them a much more affordable option for short-term financial needs.

Pros and cons of cash advances

Like anything in life, cash advances come with trade-offs.

Pros	Cons
Instant access to cash without lengthy approval processes.	Credit card cash advances charge high interest and fees.
No credit check required (for EWA options).	If not repaid quickly, interest can pile up fast.
More flexible repayment compared to payday loans.	Limits on how much you can borrow based on your credit limit or earned wages.

What is a payday loan?

A payday loan is a short-term, high-interest loan that’s meant to tide you over until your next paycheck. These loans are typically for small amounts, ranging from $100 to $1,500, and must be repaid in full, plus fees, within two weeks. The process is quick and easy, requiring only proof of income, a checking account, and a valid ID, no credit check needed.

Unlike a cash advance, which may have a set withdrawal fee or a credit card interest rate of 15% to 30%, payday loans hit you with annual percentage rates (APRs) that can soar between 300% and 600%. This means a $500 loan could cost you hundreds in fees if you can’t pay it back on time. 

Pros and cons of payday loans

Payday loans offer quick access to cash, but they come with costs and risks that borrowers should carefully consider.

Pros	Cons
Fast approval—most lenders fund loans within 24 hours.	Extremely high interest rates (300% to 600% APR).
No credit check required, making it accessible for bad-credit borrowers.	Short repayment period (usually due within two weeks).
Available in many locations, including online and physical payday loan stores.	Can easily trap borrowers in a cycle of debt if rolled over.

Key differences between cash advances and payday loans

If you’re debating between a payday loan or cash advance, understanding the differences in repayment terms, interest rates, and fees can help you make the best financial decision.

Requirements

A cash advance requires either a credit card with available credit or an EWA program through your employer or a third-party service. Credit card cash advances don’t require a credit check, but they do require a valid credit card with enough balance available. Earned wage advances typically require you to be actively employed and have direct deposit set up.

A payday loan requires a steady source of income, a checking account, and a valid ID. Most payday lenders don’t check your credit score, making them accessible for borrowers with poor credit. However, this accessibility comes at a high cost in interest and fees.

Application process 

Getting a cash advance is usually instant, especially if using a credit card cash advance at an ATM or withdrawing from an EWA service via an app. There’s no lengthy application process, and no credit check is required.

A payday loan application is still relatively quick, but it involves providing proof of income, employment verification, and signing an agreement to repay the loan in full within a short period. Many payday lenders operate online and in physical storefronts, offering same-day cash or direct deposits.

Interest rates

Payday loans have significantly higher interest rates than cash advances. A payday loan can carry an APR of 300% to 600%, making it one of the most expensive borrowing options available.

Cash advances typically have lower interest rates than payday loans, but they’re still costly. Credit card cash advances usually come with an APR of 15% to 30%. Earned wage advances often have no interest at all, though some services may charge fees.

Repayment terms

A cash advance from a credit card doesn’t have a fixed repayment deadline, you repay it like any other credit card charge, with minimum monthly payments required. 

A payday loan must be repaid in full within two weeks or by your next paycheck. If you can’t repay on time, many payday lenders allow rollovers but these come with extra fees, making repayment even more difficult.

Fees associated 

Borrowers typically pay a flat fee of $15 to $30 per $100 borrowed, plus additional fees if the loan is rolled over. 

Cash advances also carry fees, but they tend to be lower than payday loans. Credit card cash advances usually have a 3% to 5% withdrawal fee, while EWA services may charge a small fee or work on a voluntary tipping model.

Accessibility

Payday loans can be found online and in some storefront locations. However, they can also be banned in certain states. Cash advances, particularly credit card cash advances, are only available to those with a credit card that allows them. 

Earned wage access programs are growing in popularity, but not all employers offer them yet, meaning availability depends on where you work.

Alternatives to cash advances and payday loans

Before taking out a cash advance or payday loans, consider these better alternatives.

👉 Personal loans from credit unions or banks: A personal loan from a credit union typically offers lower interest rates and better repayment terms than payday loans. If you have even decent credit, this can be a much smarter borrowing option.

👉 Utilize budget-friendly credit cards: Instead of a credit card cash advance, consider using a 0% APR credit card for short-term expenses. Many cards offer interest-free periods, giving you time to repay without drowning in fees.

👉 Borrow from family or friends: Not always ideal, but if you have a trusted support system, borrowing from a loved one can help you avoid high fees and interest. Just make sure to set clear repayment terms to keep relationships intact.

Know Your Best Option Before Borrowing

When deciding between a cash advance vs payday loan, the better choice depends on your financial situation. If you need small, quick cash and have a credit card, a cash advance might be the better route. If you don’t have access to a credit card but need emergency funds, earned wage access is a smarter option than payday loans.

FAQs