Suze Orman: The $7K Car Mistake Americans Need To Avoid

Many Americans upgrade their cars before paying off their existing loans. Whether for convenience or necessity, it can come with an expensive hidden cost, according to a blog post by finance guru Suze Orman.
She called rolling unpaid debt into your next vehicle a mistake — here’s why.
Before You Sign: Here's the Math That Turns a Standard Car Loan Into a $65K Nightmare
Consider This: 14 Subtly Genius Things All Wealthy People Do With Their Money — That You Should Do, Too
The $7K Mistake
Orman drew from Edmunds.com data, which states that the average loan balance many Americans are still paying down when trading in for a new car is around $7,000. She pointed out, you’re not “trading in” $7,000, you’re adding your “existing remaining balance” to the new loan balance, a concept known as “negative equity."
Let’s look at this more closely through data provided by the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) on auto financing. Say your trade-in car is only worth $10,000, due to depreciation, but you still owe $17,000 on the original loan. You have $7,000 in negative equity.
You go to trade in your car you still have to pay that $7,000. While some dealers might pay the $7,000 to get your sale, they’ll probably find a way to pass it back to you. They might add it to the loan cost or take it from your down payment. Now, you have a much bigger loan and you still have to pay interest on that $7,000 plus the cost of your new car. You can see why it’s a problem.
Why Keeping Your Car Longer Is the Better Financial Move
Orman is judgmental of Americans’ car-buying habits, suggesting that many people replace vehicles far sooner than necessary. She sees very few good reasons for trading in a car that still has a loan balance, especially if you have to finance the new one.
"It should always be your goal to borrow as little as possible for a car,” she explained. “Period. Full stop."
A smarter move, she feels, is to stay on top of your vehicle’s ongoing maintenance and to buy cars with a track record of longevity.
According to a JD Power 2026 automotive survey, the vehicle brands that have the greatest dependability include Lexus, Cadillac, Porsche, Toyota, Buick and Chevrolet, in that order. While the average American is not likely jumping at the pricier Lexus or Porsche models and even Cadillacs may be iffy, Toyota routinely makes affordable models and they resale well.
Spending More on Maintenance Can Save Thousands Later
Orman's practical argument is that routine maintenance is far cheaper than taking on another multiyear loan. Even spending as much as $1,000 in repairs or maintenance in a year is worth extending the life of the vehicle over time.
Consumer Affairs recommended some best practices for basic maintenance including regularly getting oil changes, tire balancing and rotation, windshield wiper replacement, engine air filter and cabin air filter changes, and alignment to keep a car in its top shape.
Additionally, drivers can modify their driving behavior for optimal wear and tear, such as not speeding, braking too aggressively or idling and protecting your car from inclement weather as much as possible.
What To Do With the Money Once Your Car Is Paid Off
For those who do finally pay off their cars, Orman encouraged them to keep "paying themselves" after the loan ends instead of immediately shopping for another vehicle. She said that three to five years without a car payment is an ideal scenario.
Take that money and put it into a savings or investment account. You can even save some of it toward a downpayment on your next car.
"Being smarter about how long you keep driving the car you have makes all of that possible," she added.
According to Orman, keeping a reliable vehicle longer can create room for larger down payments, stronger emergency savings and more retirement investing over time.
This article was provided by MoneyLion.com for informational purposes only and should not be construed as financial, legal or tax advice.
More From MoneyLion: