MoneyLion
Nov 11, 2026

When To Use a Higher Withdrawal Rate in Retirement, According to Kevin Lum

The CFP challenges Dave Ramsey's advice on withdrawing from retirement portfolios.
Written by Nicholas Morine
|
Edited by Zuri Anderson
When To Use a Higher Withdrawal Rate in Retirement, According to Kevin Lum

In a recent video by certified financial planner (CFP) Kevin Lum, he addressed previous retirement advice issued by fellow finance personality Dave Ramsey, with that advice basically stating that most retirees could count on withdrawing 8% of their retirement portfolio each and every year – given that the stock market typically returns 12% annually and that about 4% can be figured to be lost to inflation at the same time.

The issue with this is, in the event of a stock market downturn, retirees end up selling shares out of their stock-heavy portfolio at the worst time, locking in losses. This is called the “sequence of return risk,” which happens between 56% to 61% of the time in an across-the-board 8% withdrawal strategy, according to Lum.

See for Yourself: Here's How Much Retirees Should Keep in an Emergency Fund

Read More: 8 Clever Ways Retirees Are Earning Up to $1K Per Month From Home

MoneyLion breaks down Lum's arguments and advice about when retirees should use a higher withdrawal rate.

Instead, Lum advised flexibility in terms of retirement withdrawals. Forget about the 8% Ramsay suggested, or the 4% across-the-board static rule that may be more conservative, Lum said.

“If you are flexible with your withdrawals, when the market is doing well, you can take a bit more. When the market is struggling, you can temporarily pull back your spending," according to the CFP. “If you do it right, it lets your spend significant more during most of your retirement."

The other essentials to consider, as he pointed out:

  • You (and any potential partners) will eventually be able to avail of Social Security income to supplement your living expenses. It may be better to delay retirement until full retirement age, or even beyond – to age 70 – and draw upon your portfolio in the early stages to allow for this.

  • A modified guardrails approach coupled with retirement planning software – Lum suggested Income Laboratory – can help you plot out your retirement withdrawals in an easy-to-understand yet comprehensive environment.

Lum admitted that his approach may be more restrained than that put forth by Ramsey.

“Now if you’re saying: ‘That sounds a lot more conservative than what Dave Ramsey said,’ Well, you’re right," he stated.

The certified financial planner and money guru underscored that his retirement withdrawal philosophy had the goals of reducing persistent anxiety among audience members, making sure that the portfolio didn’t collapse from a lack of funds, but also that delaying retirement withdrawals for too long could produce a real-life opportunity cost. That’s why flexibility and timely withdrawals backed by in-the-moment analytics was much preferred over the too-common “analysis paralysis,” he concluded.

“It’s about knowing what enough looks like, and knowing your plan can handle anything you throw at it,” Lum said.

He continued, “There are going to be years with a great plan that you could easily probably spend 7%, 8%, 9% of your portfolio – have a significant withdrawal rate. You need to be very careful, plan it well. That is often a prudent decision, particularly if you have a large amount of money that’s going to kick in in a couple of years from Social Security or a pension."

This article was provided by MoneyLion.com for informational purposes only and should not be construed as financial, legal or tax advice.

More From MoneyLion:


Nicholas Morine
Written by
Nicholas Morine
Nicholas Morine (B.A., M. Phil) is a professional writer and editor with nearly two decades of experience in the business of words.
Edited by
Zuri Anderson
Zuri is an editor with over 8 years of digital content and news experience. When she's not managing her freelance writers, voraciously editing copy and coming up with engaging stories, she's catching up on her favorite shows, books, movies and video games.