I Asked ChatGPT How Much Emergency Cash I Need — A CFP Graded the Answer
With prices rising, it seems the amount of money to have an emergency fund is ever changing. Like most questions these days, you can get a quick answer by asking ChatGPT.
However, artificial intelligence (AI) is just scraping the most popular information on the internet. Is ChatGPT’s answer for the amount of emergency cash you need accurate — or just popular?
Discover Next: You're Going To Build an Emergency Fund Even If Saving's a Struggle
Try This: Start Growing Your Net Worth With Smarter Tracking
Here’s what ChatGPT had to say and how a certified financial planner (CFP) reacted to that response. Read on to find out how much you should actually have on hand in case of an emergency.
What ChatGPT Said
ChatGPT said that how much you need in an emergency fund depends on how much your essential expenses cost each month. ChatGPT defined essential expenses as housing, utilities, groceries, insurance, transportation and debt minimums. In addition, it said to add a few thousand dollars to that if you own a home or a car for repairs.
It said the traditional amount to save is between three and six months’ worth of essential expenses, but this can shift depending on what kind of emergency you’re trying to protect yourself against. ChatGPT posted the following guide.
Your situation | Recommended emergency fund |
Stable job, dual-income household | Three to four months of essential expenses |
Stable single income | Four to six months |
Variable income (freelancer, commission, contractor) | Six to nine months |
Higher layoff risk or specialized industry | Nine to 12 months |
How a CFP Rated This Response
“Overall, I would give this advice an 8 out of 10,” said James Hargrave, CFP and founder of Pillar Financial Planning. “The area where I disagree is the approach to calculating emergency fund expenses. The recommendation suggested basing the calculation only on necessary expenses. I would argue that discretionary spending does not magically disappear when someone loses their job. Yes, most people can and should tighten their budget during a period of uncertainty, but normal monthly expenses like coffee, date nights, subscriptions, hobbies and routine home or vehicle maintenance are still part of real life.”
Instead, Hargrave said to calculate your emergency fund based on your normal monthly spending that includes discretionary expenses. However, Hargrave cautioned these discretionary purchases should be reasonable: no big vacations or luxury items.
Additionally, he recommended saving between nine and twelve months’ worth of expenses, especially for those 50 and older. “I think ageism is a real thing and people in their 50s often need six to 12 months to find a new job when laid off.”
He said he advises his clients to strive for an emergency fund that turns a potential financial emergency into a mere inconvenience. Getting laid off or having an expensive repair come up is never painless, but with an emergency fund, it makes navigating that tough time manageable. “To me, that includes not being forced to immediately make dramatic lifestyle changes during an already stressful time,” he added.
This article was provided by MoneyLion.com for informational purposes only and should not be construed as financial, legal or tax advice. It was created with the assistance of artificial intelligence and reviewed by our editorial team for accuracy. However, AI-generated content may be inaccurate, incomplete or outdated. You should independently verify important information through reliable sources before making any decisions based on this content.
More From MoneyLion: