4 Car Refinance Mistakes That Could Cost You Thousands

The cost of buying a car has increased dramatically over the past five years.
In 2021, according to Experian, the average monthly new car payment was $577. Fast-forward to 2026, per another Experian report, and that average has risen to $765, an increase of 34%. What once sounded more like a rent payment has now become the average car payment.
Learn More: Leasing vs. Buying a Used SUV: Which Option Saves More Money Over 5 Years?
Hop On: How Middle-Class Earners Are Quietly Becoming Millionaires — and How You Can, Too
Buyers are quickly realizing they may have taken on more than they are comfortable paying, leading to a significant increase in auto refinancing. According to Experian’s State of the Automotive Finance Market Report, auto refinances increased 70% year over year in Q2 2025.
If you find yourself with a monthly car payment you’re struggling to afford, you might be considering refinancing. Before you move forward, it’s important to understand that certain car refinancing mistakes could end up costing you thousands and should be avoided at all costs.
Extending the Loan Term Too Long
When refinancing a car, it can be tempting to try to lower your monthly payment as much as possible. This is the biggest trap most people fall into. If you only have two or three years left on your loan and you refinance into a new 60- or 72-month loan, you’ll drastically reduce your payment, but pay a significant amount more in interest. This is also an easy way to put yourself underwater on your loan for a longer period of time.
When you start looking at refinancing offers, remember that the lower monthly payment isn’t always the cheapest. Pay close attention to the total interest you’ll be paying.
Refinancing Without Qualifying for a Better Interest Rate
Most people refinance their cars because they hope to reduce the amount they pay each month. While this is OK, the real goal should be lowering the overall cost of borrowing. This means you should never refinance if you won’t be able to lower your interest rate. This can be done in two ways. Either interest rates have fallen since you originally bought your car or your credit has improved so you can qualify for a lower interest rate.
If you’re only refinancing for a lower monthly payment and your interest rate is the same, resetting the amortization schedule will completely wipe out any long-term benefit.
Ignoring Refinancing Fees
Borrowing money almost always comes with costs beyond interest. With a car loan, you’ll likely pay some, if not all, of the following fees:
Origination fees
Title transfer fees
DMV registration costs
Lien recording fees
State taxes (in some states)
If refinancing saves only $20 or $30 per month, the fees might eliminate the gain you’ll receive.
Before refinancing, always calculate your breakeven point. This is the number of months it takes for the cost to refinance to equal the savings you’ll receive. For example, if the fees to refinance are $2,000 and you’re saving $100 per month, it will take 20 months to breakeven.
Skipping the Credit Score Check
Many borrowers apply for a car loan without knowing their credit score. If your credit score hasn’t improved since you took out your original loan, you likely won’t qualify for a better interest rate unless the benchmark rate has dropped.
Not checking your credit score before applying can lead to a higher-than-expected interest rate. If you choose not to move forward with a loan, you’ll have had a hard pull on your credit report without a new loan to show for it.
This article was provided by MoneyLion.com for informational purposes only and should not be construed as financial, legal or tax advice.
More From MoneyLion:

