The Bond vs. Stock Decision That Changes Your Entire Retirement

According to a recent survey by SeniorLiving.org, 67% of Americans worry that a major event, such as a medical emergency, could hurt their retirement finances. With 62% admitting they have little or no confidence they’ll have sufficient funds to live comfortably in retirement, it’s more important than ever to adjust how you prepare for your golden years.
MoneyLion spoke with retirement experts to explore whether having more money in stocks or bonds will benefit your retirement portfolio more.
Good To Know: Warren Buffett's No. 1 Investing Rule That Most Americans Ignore
Read Next: 10 Low-Effort Ways To Make Passive Income (You Can Start This Week)
Investing in Bonds
“Bonds are what let you sleep at night and keep paying yourself when stocks are down,” said Jake Gurock, a CFP and a wealth advisor at Centurion Wealth Management. “Now that yields are meaningfully higher than they were a few years ago, they’re also doing a better job of generating real income.”
If you’re a conservative investor and don’t want to deal with market swings, bonds are the way to go. The downside is that bonds can lose value when rates rise, which many retirees learned the hard way in 2022.
Gurok also warned that bonds struggle to keep pace with inflation over the long run. As a result, allocating a large portion of your retirement portfolio to bonds can be risky on its own.
Robert R. Johnson, a certified financial analyst (CFA) and professor of finance at Creighton University, stressed that building wealth doesn’t come from low-risk investing. He believes that the biggest financial mistake people make is taking too little risk, not too much.
According to data compiled by Ibbotson Associates, large capitalization stocks returned 10.5% compounded annually from 1926 to 2025. Over that same time period, long-term government bonds returned 5% annually, and T-bills returned 3.3% annually.
Investing in Stocks
Gurock emphasized that stocks are your best bet for keeping up with inflation during an extended retirement lasting up to 30 years. He noted that people forget how long their retirement can be. For example, if you retire at 62, you may need this money to last into your 90s and bonds won't grow enough over time.
Johnson pointed out that the surest way to build wealth over long time horizons and to ensure that your money lasts longer is to invest in a diversified portfolio of common stocks.
“Early in their working lives, people should begin investing in a low-fee, diversified equity index fund and continue to invest consistently whether the market is up, down or sideways," he added. "Dollar-cost averaging into an index mutual fund or ETF is a terrific lifelong strategy.”
The downside to investing in stocks over bonds is the volatility and market swings, which can be unpredictable and stressful for a retiree. Gurock warned that a bad market in the first few years of retirement can do real damage if you’re forced to sell stocks while they’re down to pay the bills.
Which Is the Better Option for Retirement?
Gurock admitted that the stocks versus bonds conversation is one of the most common he has with clients nearing retirement. In his experience, the answer is rarely one or the other, since it depends on when someone needs the money.
The CFP prefers to use buckets rather than a single percentage. He urges clients to keep roughly the next several years of spending in bonds and cash, so that market swings never force a sale. Then, everything beyond that can stay in stocks and do long-term growth.
Johnson feels that people in their 40s still have a very long time horizon for retirement funds. As a result, they should be 100% invested in stocks and have no bond exposure, in his opinion. The experts agreed that being overly conservative with your retirement funds is a risk, too, because your money may not last as long.
Gurock brought up that bonds protect your next few years, while stocks protect your last few. This means that bond exposure will depend on your age and retirement horizon. The biggest risk for most retirees isn’t a stock market crash, it’s being forced to sell stocks during one.
He concluded, “The right mix comes down to how much of your spending is already covered by Social Security or a pension, and how you’d actually react to a 30% drop. Most people are less comfortable with that than they think.”
Editor’s note: Investing involves risk, including the possible loss of principal. Always consider your individual circumstances and consult with a qualified financial advisor before making investment decisions.
This article was provided by MoneyLion.com for informational purposes only and should not be construed as financial, legal or tax advice.
More From MoneyLion: